In 1587, John White left a group of 115 settlers in Roanoke Island, what is now Dare County, North Carolina. When he returned, all of the settlers were gone and never found. Get in touch on our website, HorrorStory.com Listen ad-free and bonus content on ScaryPlus.com or join Scary FM's newsletter. Find Edwin on Instagram and Twitter at @edwincov or over at edwin.fm